Return hubs: The Rwanda bluff

Reading time: 5 minutes
Commentary

Deportations to Rwanda are on shaky legal ground, are immensely expensive and will not solve one key question: what should be done with rejected asylum seekers?

Auf Deutsch.

shutterstock_2820886199.jpg

The reform of the Common European Asylum System, adopted in April 2024 and which came into force in June 2026, is often touted as a regulatory ‘turning point’: faster procedures at the external borders, stricter rules, more deportations. Yet the most controversial element of the system is only just getting started – and it is called the ‘return hub’: the deportation of rejected asylum seekers from Europe to third countries.

On Monday 16 November 2026, an initial agreement on this matter was announced with Rwanda, with great fanfare and coinciding with the high-level Vienna Migration Conference organised by the International Centre for Migration Policy Development (ICMPD). Yet the deal is ultimately a symbolic political bluff, because deportations to Rwanda rest on shaky legal ground and will have to be contested in court. They are immensely expensive and will fall far short of solving the ‘problem’ of returning large numbers of rejected asylum seekers. It also remains controversial whether the deterrent effect sought by advocates of externalisation can actually be achieved.

The new-old idea of return hubs does not solve a single structural problem in the European asylum system.

So, is this yet another manifestation of the fatal logic of externalisation that Europe has been pursuing for years? Germany, Austria, Denmark, the Netherlands and Greece see things differently: they have joined forces and negotiated with third countries on the basis of the EU Return Regulation adopted this year by the European Parliament and the EU Council. They claim to have overcome any legal ‘obstacles’ in the process. However, the principle of non-refoulement under the Geneva Convention on Refugees and Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights – which prohibit the return of people to countries where they face the risk of torture or inhuman treatment – remain in force.

Real danger

Both apply on a case-by-case basis and must be verifiable. However, a new legal basis does not make a practice lawful. It merely makes it institutionally acceptable. The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has repeatedly emphasised this, for example when, on 14 June 2022, it prevented the first flight carrying asylum seekers from the UK to Kigali, the capital of Rwanda. National courts have also made it clear that anyone seeking to transfer rejected asylum seekers en masse to a third country, without individual assessment, legal protection and effective access to proceedings, is creating a system outside the law.

Rwanda of all places, of all times: the country has a documented human rights record characterised by arbitrary detentions, limited legal protection and the questionable treatment of those seeking protection. Of course, for Kigali, ‘migration diplomacy’ brings in foreign currency, development aid and international legitimacy – a welcome boost to the legitimacy of a regime under pressure. The British Rwanda pilot scheme therefore did not fail due to a lack of Rwandan cooperation, but because the UK Supreme Court took seriously, in its ruling of 15 November 2023, the real risk of ‘chain deportation’ – that is, that people deported from Rwanda would be sent on to unsafe countries. It also failed because of the figures, as the Labour government, which came to power in 2024, took a closer look at the horrendous expenditure (more than 250 million euros in 2022 alone, whilst not a single person had been deported to Rwanda) and halted the project.

A cynical signal

At the same time, Rwanda – which is striving to overcome the consequences of a devastating genocide and is itself suffering from food insecurity – is currently hosting around 140,000 refugees from the region, housed in camps such as Mahama, Kigeme, Nyabiheke, Mugombwa, Kiziba and Gihembe. The camps lack everything, and support for those they are hosting is more lacking than ever due to serious funding shortfalls: in 2025, the World Food Programme was forced to cut food rations in the Rwandan camps. The Emergency Transit Mechanism (ETM), established in 2019 at the Gashora transit centre in Rwanda – an evacuation and repatriation programme for refugees from Libya that was largely funded by the EU – has also suffered extreme cuts. Instead of contributions based on solidarity in this context, the return hub sends a cynical signal of irresponsibility.

Not just a troublesome footnote

Europe defines itself through its values – including, and indeed particularly, in asylum policy. Anyone who sends those seeking protection to authoritarian countries outside Europe in order to relieve the pressure on their own system is betraying those values. The Geneva Convention on Refugees is not just a troublesome footnote, but forms part of the EU’s very foundations; and asylum policy does not begin at the fence of a reception centre, but with an individual procedure offering full legal protection. The funds that are symbolically squandered on ‘return hubs’ are lacking when it comes to legal advice or support during proceedings, language courses, and the integration of those seeking protection and the development of their skills – including within the European labour market, which is desperately seeking workers.

The ‘new old’ idea of return hubs does not solve a single structural problem within the European asylum system. It suggests a system of law and order that does not, in fact, work, and points to a disregard for the law and global responsibility that will ultimately have a negative impact on our societies as well.

 

This article was first published in German on derstandard.at.